Why I Don’t Buy Into the Resolution Hype


Introduction: Navigating the Resolution Maze

As the calendar does its annual flip, the tradition of New Year’s resolutions beckons many to embark on a journey of self-improvement. However, beneath the surface, lies a paradoxical tale of stress and unrealistic expectations. In the insightful words of Dr. Susan Anders, the pursuit of significant behavior changes amidst the challenges of the past year may amplify stress levels, triggering the cortisol orchestra within us (Ujek, 2020). This psychological exploration unravels the intricate dance between New Year’s resolutions, stress, and the importance of mental well-being.

Unrealistic Resolutions: A Recipe for Stress

Dr. Anders advises us to navigate the resolution maze with caution. Unrealistic New Year’s resolutions, she suggests, may multiply our angst and stress levels. It’s like deciding to run a marathon without even having a decent pair of running shoes. Ouch! Instead, she encourages a shift in focus to process goals, those small, tangible steps you can take every day that add up to the big win (Ujek, 2020). After all, in the words of Yoda, “In the present, you must live.”

Redirecting Focus: A Positive Mental Approach

Wilmington psychologist Dr. Erika Geisler, ever the sage, suggests an alternate approach to the traditional New Year’s resolutions circus. Instead of setting grandiose goals, she proposes focusing on a word or concept. It’s like choosing a theme for the year, as if life were a movie, and you’re deciding on the soundtrack. Adventure, anyone? Dr. Geisler believes that wherever we put our focus, that’s what grows (Gregory, 2021). Imagine planting seeds of positivity and watching them bloom. Green thumb, activated!

The Ripple Effect of Focus: Mind Over Resolutions

Paul Farmer, the chief executive of the mental health charity Mind, joins the chorus of focus enthusiasts. Resolutions fixated on perceived inadequacies or negatives, he warns, create a negative self-image. It’s like trying to Photoshop your life but ending up with the blue screen of death. Instead, he suggests focusing on what we can achieve. It’s akin to tuning our mental radio to a positive frequency, where we’re the DJs of our own show (Waxler, 2009).

Resolutions Realities: The Numbers Game

Diving into the statistics, a University of Scranton study reveals that while a whopping 77% of individuals make New Year’s resolutions, only a modest 19% successfully fulfill them within two years (Norcross & Vangarelli, 1988). It’s like planning a grand feast but ending up with leftovers for a week. The allure of setting unrealistic, broad resolutions proves to be a common stumbling block, leading to a mere four percent success rate according to a 2018 Statista survey (Statista Research Department, 2019).

Beyond Resolutions: A Blueprint for Well-Being

Acknowledging the pitfalls of resolutions, experts propose alternative approaches:

  1. Focus on the Good: Cultivate gratitude for what is right, fostering a positive mental environment.
  2. Reflect on Progress: Evaluate personal growth, celebrating successes to fuel motivation for the journey ahead.
  3. Comparison with Self: Avoid the trap of comparing oneself to others, embracing individuality as the true benchmark of success.
  4. Attainable Goals: Embrace the “one day at a time” philosophy, setting small, achievable goals to foster a sense of accomplishment.
  5. Resilience Amidst Setbacks: Recognize occasional slips as part of the journey, promoting resilience and preventing self-critique (Gregory, 2021).

Conclusion: A Compassionate New Year’s Narrative

As we bid farewell to a challenging year, the narrative of New Year’s resolutions unfolds as a delicate interplay of stress, psychology, and self-compassion. Redirecting our focus, setting realistic goals, and embracing the uniqueness of our journey become the guiding stars in this nuanced exploration. In the canvas of the new year, let kindness to oneself resonate as the foremost resolution.


References:

  • Gregory, D. (2021, January 01). Resolve to NOT make a New Year’s resolution. WWAY TV.
  • Norcross, J. C., & Vangarelli, D. J. (1988, January). The resolution solution: Longitudinal examination of New Year’s change attempts. ResearchGate.net.
  • Statista Research Department, S. (2019, January 8). Share of Americans who stuck to their 2018 New Year’s resolutions. Statista.
  • Ujek, W. (2020, December 31). Should you ditch the New Year’s resolution this year? One Cleveland Clinic expert weighs in! WKYC.
  • Waxler, C. (2009, January 01). New Year’s Resolutions Bad For Your Mental Health. Business Insider.

Submit a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.